Automotive Accessories

Bring a Trailer's President Calls the Comment Section Its 'Secret Sauce'

Howard Swig explains how enthusiast comments police listings, shape sale outcomes and turn auctions into a spectator sport.

Rafael LindqvistOctober 29, 20265 min read6 views

An illustrated auction hall where a classic car sits on a raised inspection platform while abstract commenter figures examine it and floating comment bubbles hover overhead.

Bring a Trailer has grown from a scrappy WordPress blog into one of the most-watched venues for enthusiast car auctions, and its president credits an unusual asset for that rise: the comment section. Howard Swig, now president of the platform, made the point on the latest episode of The Drivecast, telling The Drive that the comments have become "the secret sauce" that makes the site fun and supplies its community dimension.

Swig traced the site's origins to 2007, when it began as a simple WordPress blog and online newsletter that surfaced interesting cars found across the web, mainly on eBay and Craigslist, during what he described as a golden era for both marketplaces and for marque-specific enthusiast forums.

From listings blog to public forum

What separated Bring a Trailer from a plain aggregator, according to Swig, was the enthusiast following that built up almost immediately around each listing. The comment section, he said, is not only entertaining but also functions as a self-policing force that scrutinizes the cars on offer.

The Drive's own experience illustrates the dynamic. When the author sold a 1991 BMW E34 M5 through the site about a decade ago, during its early auction days, commenters quickly began vetting the car. One prolific member of the E34 M5 community looked up the VIN and posted the car's full build configuration in the thread, unpaid due diligence that Swig treats as part of the appeal.

Not every car, or seller, fits

That public scrutiny is not for everyone. Swig acknowledged that some sellers want privacy and maximum discretion, which a very public forum cannot offer. He suggested the format suits cars that reward explanation: an older vehicle with a complicated history, past restoration work or a mix of original and replacement parts, where buyers want to read a week of comments before bidding.

By contrast, a near-new model such as a 911 Turbo, especially in a special paint-to-sample color, is closer to a commodity and needs little question-and-answer. Swig summed up the tension with a line he likes to repeat: buyers want a car with great history but no stories, and they cannot always have both.

For sellers wary of the public ledger of opinion, Swig's advice is preparation. Listing a car with poor photos and unresolved problems, then scrambling to answer questions while the auction runs, tends to produce weak results that reflect the lack of groundwork. Doing the work beforehand, presenting the car properly and documenting what has been done, makes for a better experience, he said, though he conceded that selling is hard work compared with the fun of buying.

Moderation as umpiring

Comment moderation remains one of the site's thornier issues, as it is for any online forum. Swig described commenters as potentially first responders to major issues, and said the community can flag comments as not constructive, a mechanism in place since the early days; comments that draw enough flags can disappear, which sometimes upsets their authors.

He compared the broader task of community management to an umpire calling balls and strikes: staff try to be fair, stick to their values and get most calls right, but buyers, sellers, previous owners and commenters can each hold a valid point of view, and not every decision will please everyone.

For all the contention, the comment threads have turned BaT into something of a spectator sport. The spectacle of bidders spending large sums, with Swig citing $87,000 for a 1992 Volkswagen GTI, draws onlookers and hot takes alike. That public courtyard, in the end, is the Bring a Trailer experience.