The dispute between knackeries and the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine (DAFM) over the Fallen Animal Scheme has entered a second week, with the Animal Collectors' Association (ACA) saying that its affiliated operators will no longer collect fallen sheep and horses from this week.
The ACA also said that knackeries will not notify the department of on-farm animal deaths. The association represents knackery operators, whose collection services form part of the infrastructure for handling fallen livestock.
The withdrawal follows the expiry of the Fallen Animal Scheme on September 30. According to the ACA, fallen sheep collected by its affiliated knackery operators have not been prepared and presented to DAFM veterinary staff for scrapie sampling since Monday, October 19.
The ACA said it had sent DAFM a detailed business case before the scheme expired, setting out mechanisms for a fair and workable replacement. It said the proposal included options to limit any increase in the rates charged to farmers.
The association criticised the department's handling of the process. It said DAFM had not engaged constructively with the proposed solutions and had instead followed a pattern of waiting for schemes to expire, leaving operators to reduce services in stages.
The ACA said it remained committed to providing an environmental and biosecurity service to Irish agriculture. It called on DAFM to return immediately with a meaningful proposal that would protect the collection system without adding to farmers' costs.
DAFM said the Fallen Animal Scheme is an important part of Ireland's livestock infrastructure, providing funding that supports farmer access to fallen animal collections and protects animal health. A department spokesperson said it was continuing to engage on the matter and remained open to constructive dialogue and negotiation.
The Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers' Association (ICMSA) has also intervened. It said any solution to the dispute should not result in higher charges for farmers. Eamon Carroll, ICMSA deputy president, said the resolution must be funded from within the department's own resources.
The standstill affects more than the collection of fallen sheep and horses. The ACA's decision not to notify on-farm deaths to the department adds another point of divergence, while the suspension of scrapie sampling for collected sheep removes a disease-sampling step from the system.
With the scheme expired and no replacement agreed, the two sides remain apart on how a revised service should be funded and operated. The department has said it is available for talks; the ACA is seeking a proposal it says would preserve the collection network without shifting additional costs to farmers. ICMSA has drawn a line on farmer charges, leaving the department's funding position central to any settlement.
